Barton's Pizzeria invites you to experience authentic old world recipes right in Highland, Indiana. Since 1962, we serve up classic favorites like cheese pizza and sausage pies, crafted with recipes passed down through generations. Our extensive menu offers everything from traditional Neapolitan-style pizza to specialty cauliflower crust options. Enjoy a variety of appetizers, including mozzarella sticks and jalapeño poppers, perfect for sharing with friends or family. We feature daily specials on Facebook, making it easy to indulge in value-packed meals every day of the week. With prices between $10 and $20, our menu balances quality and affordability, ensuring a satisfying meal for lunch or dinner. Whether you’re craving a quick bite or a hearty family feast, Barton's Pizzeria delivers community flavor with every slice.
Step into Barton's Pizzeria, where casual comfort blends with a family-friendly atmosphere. Our interior features bright, welcoming decor that feels like home. We offer wheelchair-accessible seating, a clean and accessible environment designed to make every guest comfortable. The aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air as you settle into our friendly space. Whether dining in or taking out, our fast service ensures your food arrives hot and ready. Wi-Fi connectivity makes it ideal for students from nearby Highland High School or local colleges. With a lively yet cozy vibe, Barton's brings community together, whether for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with loved ones.
Celebrated for its commitment to traditional recipes, Barton's Pizzeria crafts each pie with fresh ingredients and a focus on quality. Our signature cheese pizza remains a local favorite, warmth radiating from crispy dough topped with rich, melted cheese. We also excel in unique offerings like our cauliflower crust specialty, catering to gluten-free and vegetarian diners. Our sausage and beef sandwiches are loaded with flavor, perfect for a quick, satisfying meal. Family favorites such as the Munchie Box combine pizza, wings, and breadsticks, creating a perfect combo for sharing.
At Barton's, every dish emphasizes our family-oriented roots and dedication to community. We take pride in serving hearty comfort food that reminds loyal customers of home, with friendly service that makes everyone feel like family.
At Barton's Pizzeria, we're dedicated to preserving old-world pizza traditions while continuously evolving to meet our community’s tastes. Our specialty lies in handcrafted dough, rich tomato sauces, and a range of topping options, including vegetarian and cauliflower crust choices. Being women-owned, we prioritize supporting local suppliers and sustainable practices. Our vision is to be more than a pizza place—it's a gathering spot where families, students, and neighbors build lasting memories. We are committed to fast, friendly service, high-quality ingredients, and creating a welcoming environment for all. Every slice, dip, and salad is prepared with love and precision, aiming to bring genuine flavors and communal joy right to your table.