Barton's Pizzeria

Discover Barton's Pizzeria in Highland, IN, serving authentic old-world pizza since 1962. Enjoy fast, family-friendly dining with daily specials, vegetarian options, and delivery. Perfect for lunch, dinner, or to-go bites!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Barton's Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

Barton's Pizzeria
Barton's Pizzeria
Barton's Pizzeria
Barton's Pizzeria

Step into Barton's Pizzeria, Highland's cornerstone of authentic old-world flavors since 1962. Founded by Barry Barton, our family-owned restaurant has become a local staple, known for crafting pizzas with recipes passed down through generations. We serve a diverse menu featuring classic cheese pies, hearty sausage and beef sandwiches, and vegetarian options, all made with high-quality ingredients in a warm, casual atmosphere. Our community appreciates our fast service, family-friendly environment, and commitment to customer satisfaction.

Whether you're here for lunch, dinner, or late-night bites, Barton's offers a comforting escape from the everyday. Find us at 3925 45th St, easily accessible with free parking and wheelchair-friendly amenities. When you visit, you join a legacy of neighbors and travelers alike who crave genuine flavor and friendly service.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

3925 45th St, Highland, IN 46322, United States

Phone

+1 219-924-6200

About

The Culinary Story

Barton's Pizzeria
Barton's Pizzeria
Barton's Pizzeria
Barton's Pizzeria

Barton's Pizzeria has been a family tradition in the Northwest Indiana region for over 60 years. Founded in 1962, our legacy reflects a commitment to authentic recipes, exceptional service, and community engagement. Barry Barton established a restaurant that emphasizes old-world craftsmanship—our dough is made fresh daily, and our cheese, sausage, and tomato sauce come from trusted local suppliers. Over the decades, bold flavors and heartfelt hospitality have kept customers returning and recommending us as the area’s best pizza spot. We cherish that reputation and continue to uphold it, balancing tradition with fresh innovation.

Our menus are designed to satisfy diverse tastes, including vegetarian and late-night options, ensuring everyone leaves happy. Recognized for professionalism and approachability, our team feels like part of your neighborhood family. We proudly celebrate our women-owned business status as we serve Highland and beyond, fostering a sense of local pride and community connection.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

At Barton's, we deliver much more than great pizza. Our extensive menu includes appetizers like mozzarella sticks and jalapeño poppers, plus salads, pastas, and specialty dishes such as our famous ribs and shrimp. We offer dine-in, no-contact delivery, takeout, and party-friendly curbside options. Our casual, family-oriented setting incorporates Wi-Fi, wheelchair accessibility, and comfortable seating for kids and adults alike. Our weekday specials, including unbeatable deals like a large one-topping pizza with garlic breadsticks, make indulgence affordable. We accept all major credit and debit cards, and reservations are welcome. With an emphasis on speedy service and high-quality ingredients, we aim to turn every visit into a memorable experience for local families, students, and visitors.

Barton's Pizzeria

Our restaurant welcomes you with a casual, inviting exterior that reflects our family-oriented spirit. Easy-access parking, including a spacious wheelchair-friendly lot and street parking, makes visits hassle-free. On warm days, enjoy seating outdoors where the aroma of freshly baked dough and bubbling cheese invites neighbors to relax and catch up. The outdoor vibe is welcoming, lively, and perfect for casual gatherings or quick bites. Our vibrant signage and friendly staff create a community hub where locals and visitors alike feel at home.

Whether you’re grabbing a slice for a movie night or catching up after a day at Highland’s nearby schools and parks, the outdoor space adds to our warm, approachable atmosphere.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Bartons has been my favorite pizza for over 45 years! I don't live in the area anymore but I make sure to stop in to grab a pizza to take with me whenever I'm in the area ❤️

j
jen k.

We travel from Lowell to Highland and have been going to Barton’s forever! We moved to Indiana from Connecticut 35 years ago and had the hardest time finding Pizza that reminded us of home. After trying place after place we stumbled upon Barton’s. and it’s been our pizza and calzone to-go place ever since! They are the best!

M
Michele G.

The staff exhibits a professional yet approachable demeanor. All menu items are consistently delicious, and order accuracy is consistently high. High-quality ingredients ensure food quality remains exceptional. The weekday specials are unbeatable. Ms. Nichole operates a truly exemplary pizza establishment that serves as a model for others in the industry.

D
Diane

Barton's was precisely what the doctor ordered today. Family-size Sausage Pizza was delicious, and was ready quicker than we could've made dinner! Can't wait to order again! The tomato bread sounds like it will be great too!

P
Pete D.

Absolutely best staff of any pizza place. Other place in Lansing on Ridge road is completely rude. Bartons just moved up to the top of the list

S
Scot P.

I ordered a pizza today on Super Bowl Sunday and the Bartons team did not disappoint. As busy as they were my pizza was ready right on time and delicious! They were clearly working their butts off in there, but all were friendly moving like a well oiled machine. Thank you Bartons!

M
Margaret V.